A. Zielińska, M. Zieliński
Faculty of Chemistry, Jagiellonian University, 3 R. Ingardena Str., 30-060 Krakow, Poland
Deuterium kinetic isotope effect, D-KIE, for oxidation of perdeuteriated sodium butyrate, CD3(CD2)2COONa, with manganate in the aqueous solution of 3 M NaOH has been determined in the temperature range 323-373 K. The temperature dependent kH/kD ratios are in the range from 17.59 at 323 K to 11.25 at 373 K. The activation energy difference, DQo = QoDD - QoHH = DH#oDD - DH#oHH = 9.20 kJ mol-1, and the Arrhenius preexponential factors ratio AoDD/AoHH is equal to 1.76, corresponding to DS¹oDD - DS¹oHH = 4.70 J K-1 as deduced from the Arrhenius and Eyring diagrams. This is the main evidence of tunnelling in the transfer of methylene hydrogens of butyrate to the negatively charged oxygens of manganate in very basic solutions. The koHH/koDD ratios, corrected for the ionic strengh, have been reproduced by multiplying the (kC-H/kC-D)KIE value, caused by zero point energy differences, by the Bell tunnel correction QtHH/QtDD. The half width of the energy barrier, as approximated by an inverted parabola, was found to be equal to 5·10-11 m. The physicochemical origin of the energy barrier for the oxidation of n-chain aliphatic carboxylates with MnO42- ions in strongly alkaline solutions has been discussed. The mechanisms of the permanganate versus manganate oxidation i.e., in acidic versus alkaline media are compared.